• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

MayorWatch

London News and Comment

  • NEWS
  • Twitter

TfL can no longer deliver value for money and it’s all my fault

December 20, 2012 - Martin Hoscik@MayorWatch

After years of blaming Boris for rising fares and poor value from Transport for London, I’m afraid readers will now have to reserve some of their ire for me.

By selfishly insisting on knowing how much Barclays has paid so far for the Cycle Hire scheme, I’ve enfeebled and emasculated TfL to such an extent that it’s no longer able “to secure best value for any future tenders”.

All contracts TfL enters into after December 19th 2012 will deliver worse value, and it’s my fault.

I was warned.

In August TfL told me that as “disclosure of this information would be likely to affect TfL’s bargaining power with present or future sponsors and therefore hinder its ability to obtain best value it is considered that the public interest favours the use of the exemption.”

And yet I still insisted on knowing.

If it’s no longer able to deliver value for money, it’s no longer fit for purpose. I’ve broken TfL.

Could we fix the damage by employing new negotiators? Or would it be better if Boris begins preparations to put the fatally weakened TfL out of its misery by disbanding it?

Personally I think we should harness the generosity of the season and find it in ourselves to give TfL a chance to prove it’s not quite as useless as it claimed it would be.

To conflate the giving and receiving of Christmas with the New Year tradition of making resolutions of self-improvement, we’d be entitled to ask TfL for something in return.

My ask is two-fold.

First, it’s past time for TfL to stop pretending that transparency will have the same effect on its capabilities as Kryponite does on Superman’s.

Secondly, it should stop using the guy who came up with the legend of woe and destruction should the Ravens flee the Tower to knock up its FOI responses.

Hyperbolic claims of commercial impotence look even sillier then they initially did when you finally release the ‘unreleasable’ information.

If you work at TfL but you don’t like answering to the public, you’re in the wrong job and the New Year would be a good time to look for employment elsewhere. Consider your change of career to be an act of service in helping the Mayor meet his cost reduction targets.

And on the subject of Mayors I wanted to belatedly address a question I get asked on a regular basis.

No, TfL aren’t unhelpful and secretive because Boris and his team tells them to be, they’ve always been that way. They have gotten worse in recent years but that’s simply because they’ve gotten away with it for so long that they feel ever emboldened.

After six months of being fobbed off, I only got an answer to another FOI request when Boris’s transport Deputy Isabel Dedring intervened on my behalf.

As much as I valued her help, I found it embarrassing having to ask for it. I suspect TfL felt no such embarrassment at forcing me to step outside the process and approach her.

A recent London Assembly report accused TfL of hindering its scrutiny of the Mayor’s 2013/14 budget by refusing to provide sufficient information about fare increases.

Like all formal Assembly reports, the final text of this one was agreed by all parties.

That a public body could create such strong and unified bad will among politicians from four parties that they accuse it of hampering their statutory role is a testament to something but I don’t think it’s anything good.

Unless the next Mayor makes reforming TfL his or her number one priority they’ll find themselves hearing all the same complaints that Boris and Ken before him have.

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)

RECENT UPDATES

Tube and rail users to benefit from Oyster weekly fares cap

Mayor and TfL call on ministers to help plug funding gap

Tube to get full mobile phone coverage from 2024

TfL says Direct Vision Standard is already making HGVs safer for London road users




POPULAR

City Hall to move to Docklands as Mayor seeks to raise £55m for frontline services

‘Concern’ over TfL’s ability to deliver major projects in wake of Crossrail cost overruns

City Hall halts London Overground ticket office closures but many will still see opening hours reduced

Transport for London confirms bus cuts will go ahead despite passenger opposition

GOT A STORY?

As the original London news and scrutiny site we've been casting an eye over the capital's public services and politicians since 1999.

 

Many of our top stories started with a tip-off from a reader - if you've got something you'd like us to cover get in touch and we'll do the rest.

Stay In Touch

  • E-mail
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2022 · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.