• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

MayorWatch

London News and Comment

  • NEWS

A veneer of oversight

February 23, 2010 by Martin Hoscik

commentToday the London Assembly will hold a confirmation hearing into the appointment of Kit Malthouse as Chair of the Metropolitan Police Authority.

It’s true, as political opponents are keen to point out, that the very hearing is evidence of a broken election promise on the part of a Mayor who vowed to lead the fight against crime himself.

Yet at the same time we should be gracious enough to welcome Boris Johnson’s tacit admission that the role of Mayor is so large there are limits to the fancy job titles he can lay claim to, ditto that the role of MPA Chair is too important for an occasional post-holder.

Plus, as one of the more capable members of the Johnson administration, Malthouse is likely to be better in the role than any honest assessment could conclude Boris was. His interventions at Mayor’s Question Time have frequently demonstrated a better grasp of the details than Boris could ever boast.

As someone who described themselves as ‘pro-London’ long before our former Mayor needed a name for his grand coalition, it makes sense to me to have the greater talent occupy the top post. Yet before Malthouse can officially take on the role he and the Assembly have to go through the charade of a confirmation hearing which can make only a non-binding recommendation.

It’s a pointless fudge between preserving the Mayor’s executive powers and paying lip-service to increasing scrutiny of him or her.

The issue of holding the Mayor (current and future post-holders) to account was the topic I spoke on at the recent Progressive London conference, as I said there and have many times here, there’s a clear need for increasing the scrutiny of the Mayor, including giving the Assembly power to block instances of Mayoral excess.

That said, neither democracy nor dignity are served by a sham hearing which can do nothing to alter the eventual outcome.

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Martin Hoscik

RECENT UPDATES

Tube and rail users to benefit from Oyster weekly fares cap

Mayor and TfL call on ministers to help plug funding gap

Tube to get full mobile phone coverage from 2024

TfL says Direct Vision Standard is already making HGVs safer for London road users




POPULAR

City Hall to move to Docklands as Mayor seeks to raise £55m for frontline services

‘Concern’ over TfL’s ability to deliver major projects in wake of Crossrail cost overruns

City Hall halts London Overground ticket office closures but many will still see opening hours reduced

Transport for London confirms bus cuts will go ahead despite passenger opposition

Copyright © 2023 · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy