• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

MayorWatch

London News and Comment

  • NEWS
  • COMMENT
  • Twitter

Margaret Hodge accuses TfL of “inadvertently” allowing Uber to avoid tax

August 1, 2014 - Martin Hoscik@martinhoscik

uber_appTransport for London has defended its decision to grant mini cab operator Uber a private hire licence in the wake of criticism from Labour MP Margaret Hodge.

Mrs Hodge represents the London constituency of Barking and is also chair of the Public Accounts Committee which last year examined the use of overseas entities to reduce tax liabilities.

In a letter to Mayor Boris Johnson, she suggests Uber is “competing unfairly” with other Taxi and minicab operators by basing its bookings and payments arm, Uber B.V., in the Netherlands.

This, Hodge says, “enables Uber to pay corporation tax in the Netherlands and not in the UK” and therefore allows the firm to “unfairly undercut London operators by opting out of the UK tax regime”.

The MP suggests TfL may be “inadvertently” allowing the firm to engage in “tax avoidance” by not insisting Uber B.V. be based in London and hold a Private Hire Vehicle licence.

Uber points out that it “complies with all applicable tax laws” and that the entity responsible for fulfilling bookings, Uber London Limited, holds a valid PHV licence and was recently inspected by TfL for compliance with PHV regulations.

That inspection was sparked by complaints from the Taxi trade which is concerned Uber’s use of a GPS app to determine fares breaks the law.

Commenting on Mrs Hodge’s letter, TfL’s Garrett Emmerson said: “We do not have any powers in relation to an operator’s corporate structure and how or where they pay tax.



“We are fully satisfied that based on our understanding of the relationship between passengers and Uber London, and between Uber London and Uber BV, registered in Holland, that Uber is operating lawfully under the terms of the 1998 PHV(L) Act.”

An attempt to have the High Court review Uber’s use of an app to calculate fares stalled after taxi trade representatives instigated private prosecutions of Uber drivers, preventing the High Court from hearing TfL’s application.

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)

Tagged With: Uber

Comments

  1. Damian Hockney says

    August 1, 2014 at 4:49 pm

    …and of course, TfL may not discriminate against suppliers on the basis of their lawful application of EU Single Market rules and their use of EU legislation which bars any government from hindering capital flows. If London did in fact specifically discriminate against Uber specifically on the basis of where it is legally based for tax purposes in the EU, it would surely be in breach of the law. There is no defence to lawbreaking, or any incitement to break the law, by an MP, by them suggesting that the law is ‘unfair’.

    Is Margaret Hodge suggesting that the UK should leave the EU? That is the only way any government could change this law, permit such discrimination, and make it, according to Margaret Hodge “fair”. And does she suggest that Starbucks, Amazon and Google, for example, be barred from being allowed to trade here or offer their services, on the basis that their use of tax bases within the EU allows them a competitive advantage (which of course it does)?

RECENT UPDATES

Crossrail delayed until 2021 and bosses say project could go a further £650 million over budget

TfL uses WiFi data to improve Journey Planner’s accuracy

Mike Brown to leave TfL for new role overseeing Parliament’s renovation

Transport for London seeks views on new Bakerloo line extension plans




Popular

City Hall calls in Deloitte to boost BAME progression and close ethnicity pay gap

City Hall to review pay levels amid recruitment and staff retention concerns

TfL appoints ‘Build to Rent’ partner and promises to built 3,000 new rental homes across London

TfL confirms £1bn deal to sell and leaseback Elizabeth line trains

FEATURED

City Hall halts London Overground ticket office closures but many will still see opening hours reduced

Transport for London confirms bus cuts will go ahead despite passenger opposition

City Hall and TfL publish action plan to cut lorry and van deliveries in London

TfL planning return of annual fare hikes as agency looks to balance books following Crossrail delay

GOT A STORY?

As the original London news and scrutiny site we've been casting an eye over the capital's public services and politicians since 1999.

 

Many of our top stories started with a tip-off from a reader - if you've got something you'd like us to cover get in touch and we'll do the rest.

Stay In Touch

  • E-mail
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2019 MayorWatch Publications Limited · MayorWatch is Registered Trademark · All Rights Reserved · Contact Us · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy

MayorWatch Publications Limited · 20-22 Wenlock Road · London N1 7GU · Company Number 6291816

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.