• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

MayorWatch

London News and Comment

  • NEWS
  • Twitter

High Court’s Uber ruling vindicates TfL’s managers

October 16, 2015 - Martin Hoscik@MayorWatch

Uber_Logo_Black_BackgroundToday’s ruling that Uber’s app doesn’t breach the ban on minicabs using taximeters isn’t just good news for the firm but an important vindication of Transport for London.

Ever since the agency, which doubles as regulator for the minicab and taxi cab trades, approved the firm’s application to open offices in London it’s been accused of tacitly sanctioning illegal activity.

Cabbies, commentators and some politicians have repeatedly asserted that the illegality of the app was obvious for all to see unless, as some claimed, you were taking bungs from the firm.

Then along came MPs who lambasted TfL for not exceeding its remit and seeking to impose conditions on Uber which changed its tax structure, and potential mayoral candidates who said they’d have blocked Uber’s application and challenged them to take TfL to judicial review.

Such interventions are a great way to win headlines but they’re not an appropriate way for a regulator to behave.

Had TfL tried to barter a licence in return for Uber changing its tax status it would have rightly faced a successful legal challenge for exceeding the powers Parliament gave it.

And had managers ignored their own lawyers’ hideously expensive advice that the app was legal and refused the licence application, today’s ruling removes any doubt about how easily Uber could have overturned that decision.

In both cases London tax and fare payers would have faced paying Uber hundreds of thousands or even millions of pounds in damages. How would the tax campaigners have felt about that?

The law has now been clarified at minimal cost to the taxpayer and can now be upheld.

Which is why TfL’s decision to approve Uber’s operations, explain why it thought the app was legal and ask a court to confirm or overturn its reasoning was not, as some claim, a waste of public cash but, to quote the judge, “the right course” for it to have followed.

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)

Tagged With: Uber

RECENT UPDATES

TfL and Siemens unveil new Piccadilly line Tube train designs

852 new homes to be built in Acton by Transport for London

HGV operators in London urged to apply for a Direct Vision Standard permit

TfL proposes bus and tube cuts and annual fares increases to achieve long-term financial sustainability




Popular

1,700 extra Santander Cycles are coming to London’s streets

TfL confirms changes to Older Person’s Freedom Pass and 60+ Oyster card hours

TfL fares to rise in return for £1.6bn Government rescue package

Election for Mayor of London and London Assembly postponed until 2021

FEATURED

City Hall to move to Docklands as Mayor seeks to raise £55m for frontline services

‘Concern’ over TfL’s ability to deliver major projects in wake of Crossrail cost overruns

City Hall halts London Overground ticket office closures but many will still see opening hours reduced

Transport for London confirms bus cuts will go ahead despite passenger opposition

GOT A STORY?

As the original London news and scrutiny site we've been casting an eye over the capital's public services and politicians since 1999.

 

Many of our top stories started with a tip-off from a reader - if you've got something you'd like us to cover get in touch and we'll do the rest.

Stay In Touch

  • E-mail
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2021 MayorWatch Publications Limited · MayorWatch is Registered Trademark · All Rights Reserved · Contact Us · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy

MayorWatch Publications Limited · 20-22 Wenlock Road · London N1 7GU · Company Number 6291816

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.